Revision Practice Essay

Having drafted your essay, you have gained the perspective of hindsight. Was the subject matter more complex than you anticipated? Did your preconceived ideas prove less interesting than discoveries you made while writing? Would you like to revise, but feel uncertain about how to do so? 

How to revise:

  • Put your draft aside. Time away from your essay will allow for more objective self-evaluation.
  • Get feedback. Since you already know what you're trying to say, you aren't always the best judge of where the draft is clear or unclear. Let another reader tell you. Then discuss aloud what you were trying to achieve. In articulating for someone else what you meant to argue, you will clarify ideas for yourself.
  • Construct a backward-outline of your essay. Identify the main idea(s) in each paragraph. Rank their importance in advancing your thesis. Consider connections between and among ideas.
  • Rethink your thesis. Based on what you did in the previous step, restructure your argument: reorder your points, cut irrelevancies or redundancies, add complications and implications. You may want to return to the text for additional evidence.
  • Now that you know what you're really arguing, work on the introduction and conclusion. Make sure to begin your paragraphs with topic sentences, linking idea(s) in each paragraph to those proposed in the thesis.
  • Proofread. Aim for precision and economy in language. Read aloud so you can hear stylistic infelicities. (Your ear will pick up what your eye has missed.)

An example of revision:

In 1969, E. B. White wrote a one-paragraph comment on the first moon walk. Eventually, White took the comment through six drafts. On the next page of this hand-out, you can see his third and sixth drafts. White's main points are underlined. In Draft 6, White gets right to the point. He states the problem he's addressing—"the moon is a poor place for flags"—in his third sentence. In Draft 3, he does not suggest this until the sentence that begins "Yet," and never directly; it is the sum of the large amount of underlined material. Revision enabled White to be clearer by articulating concisely and directly an idea that was earlier implied; correspondingly, revision let him move an idea that was clear by the middle or end of an early draft to the beginning. He also cut his introductory device, the beach trip. The amount of space he devotes to it in draft 3 suggests that White was attached to this example. But it prevents him from getting to the point. So he substitutes the bouncy dance, which preserves the playfulness of the trip to the beach but is more economical. 

Draft 3: 

Planning a trip to the moon differs in no essential respect from planning a trip to the beach. You have to decide what to take along, what to leave behind. Should the thermos jug go? The child's rubber horse? The dill pickles? These are the sometimes fateful decisions on which the success or failure of the whole outing turns. Something goes along that spoils everything because it is always in the way; something gets left behind that is desperately needed for comfort or for safety. The men who drew up the moon list for the astronauts planned long and hard and well. (Should the vacuum cleaner go, to suck up moondust?) Among the items they sent along, of course, was the little jointed flagpoles and the flag that could be stiffened to the breeze that did not blow. (It is traditional among explorers to plant the flag.) Yet the two men who stepped out on the surface of the moon were in a class by themselves and should have been equipped accordingly: they were of the new breed of men, those who had seen the earth whole. When, following instructions, they colored the moon red, white, and blue, they were fumbling with the past—or so it seemed to us, who watched, trembling with awe and admiration and pride. This moon plant was the last scene in the long book of nationalism, one that could have well been omitted. The moon still holds the key to madness, which is universal, still controls the tides that lap on shores everywhere, still guards lovers that kiss in every land under no banner but the sky. What a pity we couldn't have forsworn our little Iwo Jima scene and planted instead a banner acceptable to all—a simple white handkerchief, perhaps, symbol of the common cold, which, like the moon, affects us all! 

 Draft 6: 

The moon, it turns out, is a great place for men. One-sixth gravity must be a lot of fun, and when Armstrong and Aldrin went into their bouncy little dance, like two happy children, it was a moment not only of triumph but of gaiety. The moon, on the other hand, is a poor place for flags. Ours looked stiff and awkward, trying to float on the breeze that does not blow. (There must be a lesson here somewhere.) It is traditional, of course, for explorers to plant the flag, but it struck us, as we watched with awe and admiration and pride, that our two fellows were universal men, not national men, and should have been equipped accordingly. Like every great river and every great sea, the moon belongs to none and belongs to all. It still holds the key to madness, still controls the tides that lap on shores everywhere, still guards the lovers that kiss in every land under no banner but the sky. What a pity that in our moment of triumph we did not forswear the familiar Iwo Jima scene and plant instead a device acceptable to all: a limp white handkerchief, perhaps, symbol of the common cold, which, like the moon, affect us all, unites us all! 

As you revise your own work, keep the following principles in mind:

  • Revision entails rethinking your thesis. Because clarity of vision is the result of experience, it is unreasonable to expect to come up with the best thesis possible—one that clearly accounts for the complexities of the issue at hand—before beginning a draft, or even during a first draft. The best theses evolve; they are the products of the kind of precise thinking that is only possible to achieve by writing. Successful revision involves bringing your thesis into focus—or, changing it altogether.
  • Revision entails making structural changes. Drafting is usually a process of discovering an idea or argument. Your argument will not become clearer if you only tinker with individual sentences. Successful revision involves bringing the strongest ideas to the front of the essay, reordering the main points, cutting irrelevant sections, adding implications. It also involves making the argument's structure visible by strengthening topic sentences and transitions.
  • Revision takes time. Avoid shortcuts: the reward for sustained effort is a clearer, more persuasive, more sophisticated essay than a first draft can be.

Copyright Laura Saltz, 1998, and the President and Fellows of Harvard College, for the Writing Center at Harvard University.

The following are two short essays done for this week's assignment. Essay Two: Learning to Teach NOTE: Both essays have been revised according to the assignment. Additions are shown in red, deletions in strikethrough, and comments inside [brackets] 

A Summer Lesson (Brad�s Second Draft)

NOTE: This essay has been revised according to the assignment. Additions are shown in red, deletions in strikethrough, and comments inside [brackets]

     In 1974, I worked as a bull cook (helper) in a summer drilling camp in Canada�s Northwest Territories. That year, I had some trouble and learned a fewvaluable lessons. [made thesis simpler and more direct; added a definition of "bull cook"]

     At the beginning of thatthe summer, I followed the cook�s directions, but not enough to avoid trouble. One day early on, I had returned to my tent after breakfast to settle down and read a novel. The cook came in, yelled at me, and demanded that I return to the kitchen tent immediately. He wanted me to sweep the floor, something he had not asked me to do. I said that he hadn�t, andso, but that made him even angrier! [reduced number of words without changing meaning] My hands shook as I swept the room that morning. I didn�t go back to my tent until I was sure I had followed all his directions.

     At first, I was angry with him and felt that he had done me wrong. It was clearseemed to me that he hadn�t even asked me to do the sweeping. [change to meaning closer to the truth!] Of course, I would have done it had he only asked in the first place. I felt very alone and far away from home. The cook, in my opinion, had mistreated me and I thought then that, and it would be a very long summer, indeed,  working for such a mean man. [of course it is "my opinion"; no need to tell you that!] In all my previous jobs, no one had ever treated me like that, so I was sure I had been wronged.

     In the end, however, I learned a valuable lesson, one that I�ve carried to this day. It became clear to me over the summer that I had a job to do�I was the cook�s helper after all. ["to me" same as "in my opinion"; unnecessary]  He was cooking three meals a day for 23 fussy men, many of them lonely for their wives and families. Complaints to both him and me were frequent and, though often unfounded. What he and I needed to do, I figured out at the time realized, was work as a team to do the job, together. [one word, "realized" replaces five] If something needed to be done, I should be smart enough to see it, too. Finally, I understood what my own mother had been trying to get me to see around my own home through my teenage years!

     I was never bull cook again, and never worked so far away from home, but I have never forgotten thatthe valuable lesson I learned in my 18th eighteen. [just sounds better, that's all]

Learning to Teach (Brad�s Second Draft)

NOTE: This essay has been revised according to the assignment. Additions are shown in red, deletions in strikethrough, and comments inside [brackets]

     In 1987, as a new teacher, I taught adult night school rather badly at first, but eventually learned from my early experiences. ["early" is assumed by "new teacher"; "rather" adds nothing]

     My teaching methods at the time were much different than now. Before the beginning of every class, I copied many pages of notes from various grammar and reading texts onto the blackboard. ["the beginning of" assumed by "before"; "various" redundant] My students were required to spend a lot of time transcribing these notesThis , an activity that took much of my class time every evening. [combined to make better, longer sentence] Then, with the little time left, I would go around to see individual students and look at their work. One evening, it became clear to me that a some of my students were frustrated by my approach to teaching., and not too long after, they had quit my class.

     At the time, I felt a little upset, but wasn�t too clear on why this had happenedthey had left. [made clearer what had happened] It seemed to me then that the material I had presented was well chosen and important. [who else would present?] The grammar came from a good and humourously written text, the reading from an approved GED textbook. And some of my students had stayed, dutifully transcribing my notes night after night. [italics for emphasis] They were happy enough, it seemed to me then. Although I knew that there was something wrong inwith my approach, I wasn�t quite sure exactly what it was. [overly wordy]

     A teacher�s lessons come with experienceA responsible teacher learns from mistakes, and I now knowrealize now of whatthe limited value of some of my classroom teaching had been in those early days. The technology of the classroom has changed, but that wasn�t the real problem. [off topic] My real worry had actually been about how to fill up the time, how to make sure the students were busy. Little did I know how much fun my interaction with students in group discussion wouldcould be, and how essential to their progress and enjoyment. Now, I only wish I could go back in time, knowing what I know today, and meet them again, and really teach them well.

     A teacher�s job features never-ending revelations of human nature and of how people learn.As a teacher, I have learned much on the job, and continue to apply this knowledge to improving my teaching practice. Certainly, I will never be bored as long as I continue in this work.It's certainly never boring! [off topic and not a summation of the essay; better now, I think]


Back to top

One thought on “Revision Practice Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *